A structural shift may be underway in Russia-Ukraine peace talks, with Europe poised to join core negotiations alongside the United States, Russia and Ukraine.
Experts say European participation could help steer the process toward a more comprehensive peace, but warn that it could also complicate coordination and efforts to balance diverse interests.
The role of Europe in the talks and the continent's future security architecture have emerged as key issues since trilateral talks involving Russia, Ukraine and the US concluded in Abu Dhabi last week. US special envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner subsequently visited Moscow, where Witkoff expressed hope for multilateral talks involving European representatives.
However, the following diplomatic signals were mixed. Witkoff said Russia had agreed to European participation, while the Kremlin took a more cautious stance, saying Europe must first show its readiness to contribute to the peace process before its involvement can be decided.
The issue gained fresh momentum on Monday, when Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said Ukrainian, US and European negotiators had held their first joint talks on future negotiations with Russia. Witkoff and Kushner joined the online meeting.
Kushner said the parties were making progress through close coordination among Russia, Ukraine and Europe toward an outcome that could end the nearly five-year conflict, strengthen European security and lay the groundwork for lasting peace.
Fighting, however, continued. Ukraine struck the Crimean bridge for a second day on Tuesday, while Russian forces hit two bridges over the Dnieper River in Kyiv and other infrastructure late on Monday.
Cui Hongjian, a professor at Beijing Foreign Studies University's Academy of Regional and Global Governance, said Washington's push to involve Europe reflects a belated recognition that the conflict cannot be resolved by focusing on Ukraine alone.
"Without raising the issue of a European security architecture, the Ukraine conflict cannot truly achieve a long-term and sustained resolution," he said.
Long Jing, deputy director of the Center for European Studies at the Shanghai Institutes for International Studies, pointed to a more transactional US motive. She said Washington's proposal for a new European security architecture aligns with its previous demand for increased defense spending by NATO members.
The strategy, Long said, would ease the US burden of providing security to Europe while ensuring its economic interests through increased European military procurement.
However, a major obstacle to Europe's direct involvement is its difficulty in forging a unified negotiating position and agreeing on who should represent it.
After months of hesitation, European Union leaders agreed on Friday that EU institutions and the E5 group of the Coalition of the Willing would form Europe's negotiating team for Ukraine peace talks.
Wan Qingsong, a professor at East China Normal University's Center for Russian Studies, said Europe's negotiating lineup is essentially a stopgap response.
"Europe lacks sufficient consensus on both the composition of its negotiating team and the goals of the peace talks. The current lineup is a compromise — a patchwork of major powers with institutional backing," he said. "Such internal friction tends to preclude efficient collective action at the table, let alone a clear, comprehensive and lasting peace plan."
The experts agreed that Europe's direct participation in the peace talks could be a double-edged sword. Cui said that as Kyiv's largest provider of military and financial aid, Europe had gained considerable leverage over the Ukraine issue and broader European security.
However, its influence also comes with significant baggage. Wan warned that its involvement would inevitably create "new divisions and obstructions".
The EU insists on a ceasefire before discussing a security framework and views military support for Ukraine as essential to its own security — positions fundamentally at odds with Russia, which refuses to give up its leverage first and sees Ukraine's integration into Western defense structures as a new security threat, he said.
Agencies contributed to this story.
yangran1@chinadaily.com.cn
