Courts of original verdicts to hear retrials
Updated: 2012-09-01 03:34
By ZHAO YINAN (China Daily)
|
||||||||
Cases involving more than one plaintiff or defendant will be retried in the same court that handed down the original verdict, an amendment to the Civil Procedure Law passed on Friday has ruled, prompting concerns there will be less opportunities to overturn disputed verdicts.
Lawmakers said the change will mainly affect cases on environmental and food safety issues.
The change, which will be put into effect in January, differs from current rules that require all retrials to be heard in a higher court, a practice started in 2007 to encourage courts to correct wrong verdicts.
The growing number of retrials has led to an increased workload at provincial-level courts and the country’s top court, the Supreme People’s Court.
Wang Shengming, a lawmaker from the National People’s Congress, said the change is aimed at improving judicial efficiency.
Li Shishi, deputy director of the NPC Law Committee, said on Monday that environmental pollution and unsafe food cases usually involve a large number of parties.
Courts of original jurisdiction are in a better position to conduct a thorough investigation, he said.
"It is also in line with the principle of resolving the conflict at the local level," he said.
The move has been met with mixed feeling among experts, with some arguing the decision reflects a conservative attitude from governments in addressing issues involving the public interest.
Tang Weijian, civil procedure professor at Renmin University of China, said he worries that the stipulation will complicate retrials.
Tang suspected it would be difficult for some local courts to admit they made a wrong judicial decision, either out of pressure from local governments or fear of being held accountable for wrong verdicts.
"Cases related to environmental pollution and food safety are usually raised against local enterprises, which are important taxpayers. They may have an influence on the local government," he said.
Chen Sixi, lawmaker of the NPC Standing Committee, said having a disputed verdict heard in a higher court is beneficial in promoting public trust in the judicial system.
zhaoyinan@chinadaily.com.cn
- Relief reaches isolated village
- Rainfall poses new threats to quake-hit region
- Funerals begin for Boston bombing victims
- Quake takeaway from China's Air Force
- Obama celebrates young inventors at science fair
- Earth Day marked around the world
- Volunteer team helping students find sense of normalcy
- Ethnic groups quick to join rescue efforts
Most Viewed
Editor's Picks
Supplies pour into isolated villages |
All-out efforts to save lives |
American abroad |
Industry savior: Big boys' toys |
New commissioner
|
Liaoning: China's oceangoing giant |
Today's Top News
Health new priority for quake zone
Xi meets US top military officer
Japan's boats driven out of Diaoyu
China mulls online shopping legislation
Bird flu death toll rises to 22
Putin appoints new ambassador to China
Japanese ships blocked from Diaoyu Islands
Inspired by Guan, more Chinese pick up golf
US Weekly
Beyond Yao
|
Money power |