Making it mine - copyright or copy wrong?
Updated: 2014-07-18 09:14
By Erik Nilsson (China Daily)
|
||||||||
Iowa expat finds China connection |
Excuse me, while I check my phone |
It argues "yoga theft" defies the very soul of the spiritual practice. Not only does yoga belong to the cultural commons but by no stretch of the imagination are the patents based on innovation. Rather, they're based on the usurpation of something that belongs to traditional and modern Indian culture, and, arguably, to us all.
While the Happy Birthday case shows what could happen if China allows cultural heritage to be patented provincially or nationally, the yoga case reveals the dangers if it doesn't protect itself from overseas entities' patenting.
If Americans can patent yoga moves, what's to stop a foreign entity from claiming property rights over the peacock dance's hand gestures? The patterns of particular traditional Chinese opera masks? Shandong brocade? (Yuan points out the brocade genre has already led to intellectual property lawsuits among Chinese companies.)
There is room for debate about whether true innovations on intangible cultural heritage should be available for patenting - that is, provided they're really innovations upon, rather than confiscations of, heritage. Both copyright and "copy left" advocates make good points on this.
But there's less space for debate when it comes to the question of takers versus makers - those who appropriate rather than create our cultural commons.
- Star Stefanie Sun holds concert in Beijing
- Faye Wong's manager refutes star's drug rumors
- Lu Yi and daughter Bei Er pose for street snaps
- Photoshoots of actress Li Xiaomeng
- Council of Fashion Designers of America Awards
- Fan Bingbing, first Chinese actress in Barbie Hall of Fame
- Awarding ceremony of 2014 hito Pop Music held in Taipei
- Zhao Liying's photo shoot for Children's Day
Most Viewed
Editor's Picks
Xi attends BRICS summit |
China helps fight international war on drugs |
Crackdown on terrorist attacks |
My China Story: Meeting the master |
Tongues tied around tatu-bola |
A market that's not such a hot property |
Today's Top News
Ex-security chief Zhou Yongkang under probe
Prudence urged over solar dispute
US visa delays likely to continue
McDonald's fishing for supplier
OSI group to fund food safety
China's FDI in US set for increase
Glitch delays visas for US-bound students
A musical spoof of the Clinton years
US Weekly
Geared to go |
The place to be |