Court overrules passenger's request for compensation after he drank own water during subway security check
By Quan Zhanfu | chinadaily.com.cn | Updated: 2023-10-29 19:45
A court in southern China has overruled a passenger's request for compensation after he drank his own water during a subway security check and became physically unwell.
The Guangzhou Daily reported Thursday that Zhang, a passenger in Guangzhou, Guangdong province, was asked to undergo a liquid test by security on Dec 14, 2022, as he was found carrying liquid. Zhang drank the bottled water he had with him and was subsequently allowed to board the subway.
Zhang later claimed that the water he drank was boiled water, and his preexisting gastrointestinal condition caused extreme discomfort after consuming the water. Zhang filed a lawsuit against Guangzhou Metro, seeking compensation totaling 48,100 yuan ($6,600) for medical expenses, loss of income, nutrition expenses, and mental damages.
The Railway Transportation Court of Guangzhou determined that Zhang's claim of infringement caused by Guangzhou Metro lacked factual and legal basis, and therefore rejected Zhang's claims for compensation.
The court emphasized that the security measures implemented by Guangzhou Metro, such as the installation of security checkpoints and the requirement for passengers to undergo liquid tests by a liquid detector or drinking for inspection if carrying liquid, are obligations that railway operators should fulfill to ensure safety of the passengers.
Furthermore, the court found that Zhang failed to provide evidence to substantiate his claims for medical expenses, loss of income, nutrition expenses, and mental damages.
The judge pointed out that security checkpoints are one of the most effective preventive measures that public transportation operators can take when dealing with potential security threats. Such measures, such as liquid test, are reasonable and necessary, and passengers should try their best to understand and follow the measures.
Guangzhou Metro has also issued notices reminding passengers of the security inspection procedures during entry. Passengers can also hand over their water cups or beverages to the staff for testing.
